
The best way I could think of to describe this app is as a synchronic reading experience. Because you can only focus on one word at a time, the rest of the text—what I consider to be the past and future of a book, or a kind of diachronic / temporal scale—disappears, or is erased. At first I thought that such an approach to reading must be one that is unique to digital text, but a few years ago I had to read Gertrude Stein's Tender Buttons for a class. It's a really bizarre experience: each word you read seems to make sense, at the time, as existing in a sequence, but after only a few words, you have no idea how you got to where you are, or what connection exists between this word, and the word you started with. I don't think that makes any sense, but it's the best way I can think of describing what it's like to read Tender Buttons. Actually, another way might be to think of the ground disappearing beneath your feet so that it always feels like you're on solid ground, but when you look back, there's nothing there... Perhaps it is best summed up by Stein's essay Composition as Explanation: "In the beginning there was the time in the composition that naturally was in the composition but time in the composition comes now and this what is now troubling every one the time in the composition is now a part of distribution and equilibration." (or not). If I remember correctly, the central idea is that the moment of composition is always now.
I am realizing now that perhaps I did not make a very clear connection between the Spritz app and Gertrude Stein... All I mean is that when words flash on the screen in front of you, totally isolated from the rest of the text, I think that it encourages a synchronic reading of the text in a way that might not be very different from Stein's continuous present. While I have very little interest in reading Proust using the Spritz app, I am kind of interested in reading Stein in this format.
I wonder if there have been any studies about retention and the Spritz app. I can believe that you can comprehend the text as it comes at you that fast, though I doubt I'd want to read a book that way, but how well can you remember what you read? I know that for myself, I tend to remember more of the details of books that I read over the course of several weeks rather than those I barge through in a day or two. It gives me time to mull over and digest what I read. If I read an entire book on the Spritz app, I don't think I'd be able to retain many details at all.
ReplyDeleteI definitely think the speed would be an issue for retention for me, but I am more interested in knowing whether or not it makes a difference for retention to not actually see all of the words printed on the page all at once. With some books (especially dense/difficult ones) you need to go back and read over sections before you can understand what's going on. I have no idea if Spritz allows for this kind of re-reading.
ReplyDeleteI also remember more details if I spend more time with a book, but that might be because if I read a book quickly, I am typically skimming it and therefore actually skipping over words. It seems like with the Spritz app you don't actually skip any of the words, just absorb them much more quickly. I'm not sure how much of a difference that would make...